Premier Pizza Reviews

Premier Pizza has an overall rating of 2.8 based on 16 reviews. Customer feedback on Premier Pizza is mixed.

2.8/5.0

16 reviews

5 Stars

3

4 Stars

1

3 Stars

7

2 Stars

0

1 Star

5

All Premier Pizza Reviews (16)
RobertKirby
May 30, 2026
"Huge slices, wish I hadn’t ordered so much"
The slices were way bigger than I expected and filled me up fast. i kind of regret getting as much as I did because I couldn’t finish it all, but it was still a good deal.
james_Olds94
May 28, 2026
"I ordered from Premier Pizza, and maybe..."
I ordered from Premier Pizza, and maybe it was just an off day, but the toppings didn’t really taste fresh to me. The peppers were kind of soggy, the cheese seemed a bit dry, and the crust had that reheated sort of taste. I might’ve just gotten a bad pizza, but overall it wasn’t great. I probably wouldn’t order from there again
hello_terry520
May 25, 2026
"i was happy with how many options Premier..."
i was happy with how many options Premier Pizza had on the menu. It wasn’t just the basic cheese or pepperoni stuff either, they had different toppings, crust choices, sides, and even a few things that worked for the picky eaters in my family.
Ordering ended up being way easier than usual because everyone found something they wanted. The site was simple to use, the choices were solid, and it didn’t turn into a whole stressful thing. I’d definitely order from them again
David-newlon
April 22, 2026
"Pizza wasn't bad, but the place could be cleaner"
The pizza was fine, wasn't nothing amazing, but it did the job. The dining area just didn't feel all that clean. There were crumbs on the tables, and the floor by the counter looked kind of sticky. The staff were nice enough and the service was quick, I just wish the place felt a little more looked after
Iris_critchfield72
March 21, 2026
"I had a frustrating experience..."
I had a frustrating experience with their support. The person I spoke with came across as rude, and I didn’t feel like I got any real help. It just felt like they wanted to get me off the chat instead of actually fixing the issue.
FUNK
March 08, 2026
"Pizza showed up kind of cold?!"
The delivery actually got here on time, but the pizza was already lukewarm when I opened the box?! It tasted fine after I reheated it, but I definitely wish it had arrived hotter
hello_joseph225
March 05, 2026
"Mostly Right, Can’t Really Complain"
The pizza showed up with all the toppings I asked for, and the drinks were there too, so that was a relief. They did send the wrong dip, which was a little annoying, but I guess it wasn’t a huge deal in the end. Overall it was decent, and yeah, I’d probably order again.
kathleen1977
March 03, 2026
"Pizza was just okay"
The pizza was kind of bland, nothing really stood out. What bothered me more was that after I paid, I started feeling a bit uneasy about the whole experience, like I wasn’t totally sure it was worth what I’d spent. Not terrible, but I probably wouldn’t rush back
hello_nicole540
February 09, 2026
"I ordered from premier-pizza.com, and when the..."
I ordered from premier-pizza.com, and when the pizza arrived, it was already cold and one of the sides was missing. I took photos right away and contacted support that same night, hoping it would be something they could sort out easily.

They did reply once asking for my order number, but after I sent it over, I didn’t hear anything for days. I followed up twice and only got a vague message saying they were “looking into it,” which just felt like I was being brushed off.
I never got a refund, replacement, or even a real apology. I get that mistakes happen, but being ignored made the whole thing feel much worse, and it left me disappointed. I wouldn’t feel comfortable ordering from them again.
CORLEY
February 06, 2026
"Had to Wait Forever for Cold Pizza"
This was really frustrating. I waited almost two hours for my pizza, and by the time it finally showed up, it was cold. I felt like I was practically begging just to get the food I already paid for, which left me resentful about the whole experience.
juliarush6280
February 04, 2026
"Picking up my takeout was pretty..."
Picking up my takeout was straightforward, which I appreciated, but the wait felt longer than I expected. The food was okay overall, nothing bad, just not quite something I’d be excited to rush back for.
christina1987
February 01, 2026
"Delivery can be a bit unpredictable"
I’ve had the pizza show up late a couple of times now. It was still warm, which I appreciated, but I’ll admit I started wondering if the delivery estimate was a little too good to be true. The food was fine, but the timing feels hit or miss.
RAY
January 11, 2026
"Friendly service, pizza was just okay"
The staff was nice and answered my questions without any hassle, so the service part was fine. The pizza wasn’t bad, but it also didn’t really stand out. Because the experience was decent but not anything special, 3 stars feels about right.
shawn_Baldwin91
December 30, 2025
"Crust was kinda hit or miss"
Not gonna lie, the crust just wasn’t really my thing. It was a bit too chewy for me, so I didn’t enjoy it as much as I hoped.
SaraLacosse_36
December 10, 2025
"Not worth the price"
This just wasn’t worth what I paid. I expected a lot more for the price, and even a basic request I made was ignored, which made the whole experience even more frustrating. I wouldn’t buy it again.
Thomas_hanna76
December 10, 2025
"Pretty smooth ordering experience"
I ordered pizza through the site and, reading between the lines, it felt like they’ve got the process figured out. Checkout was quick, nothing weird popped up, and the updates were actually helpful. The pizza showed up as expected, so overall it was an easy, no-stress experience...
Have a question about Premier Pizza?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.